By Star Morales
Although only vaguely familiar with the work of Kathleen Hanna from her time in political dance-punk trio Le Tigre, I boldly decided to purchase a ticket to see Rah! Rah! Replica, a tribute to celebrate the music of Hanna, and also a benefit and video shoot to support a documentary by Sini Anderson. It seemed fun and a good way to get to know more of her music, even if they were just covers.
You might already know that Hanna is considered a feminist icon in the punk rock world and is a founder of the '90s Riot Grrrl Movement. She's a political activist who has worked to respond to sexism in punk and has a do-if-yourself ethic. She's a rebel girl, speaking out about the issues that matter to her without fear. This is inspiring. She's a voice to those in need and that's a powerful thing. But we haven't heard from her much recently. She's done collaborations here and there and some production work for Christina Aguilera's last album Bionic, but none of her own music. So why are we hearing about her now? First, a documentary is being made about her career. Second, there's also Hanna's new band, which world premiered a new song and played some music from her project Julie Ruin and even threw in a Le Tigre song. The band featuring Kathi Wilcox from Bikini Kill and they called themselves The Julie Ruin. Cool, right?
The sold out show was packed with presumably big time Kathleen Hanna fans from New York or currently living in New York and fans of all ages in a true sort of D.I.Y. setting, even though this was not at what you'd consider a D.I.Y. space. The venue gave me a similar feeling to that of the old Knitting Factory's tribeca NYC space: a venue you could be free to express yourself in with no barricade or security guards or idiots in the crowd. Everyone takes care of each other. For this tribute to a punk feminist icon there was more dancing and singing along than highly spirited punk fist pumping, two-stepping, and most pits. I'm not sure what the crowd reaction was to Bikini Kill and Le Tigre in their heyday, but the show seemed to lack a crowd energy. at points. Sure there was cheers of excitement and moving but I felt like something was missing. There was no need to worry about getting hurt or pushed or anything and for a sold out the room was comfortable, packed which is a testament to the respectful crowd and nature of the music of Hanna. But part of me just wanted to go nuts for some songs but it didn't seem appropriate. Everything was happening so fast, and I was trying to document it, and pay attention to the music and performers all during any particular song. Though, I picked a few opportunities to enjoy the music. I sang during Toshi Reagon's version of "Keep on Living" and danced around to Care Bears of Fire's stellar, loud, fun, punk rock performance of "My, My Metrocard" and headbanged d to Hilly Eye's angsy version of "Bang! Bang!" These were some of my standout moments where I was able to let loose.
Now, the only known similarity between everyone at this show was an interest, perhaps, a love or like for Kathleen Hanna's music. Some may have just liked Bikini Kill, others Julie Ruin, or like myself Le Tigre. So does it matter who made up the audience? I think not, but the different types of people in the crowd does speak to perhaps the market or appeal of the music that was brought to perhaps only a few different types of people, if the 300 people in the room was to be taken as a sample of who likes Hanna's music. I feel that the issues and concerns Hanna speaks of could appeal to all kinds of people, like women of color, to provide just one example. But where were the Hispanics at the show? I don't think I knew or saw any, except a friend who is half Puerto Rican. But a conversation with fellow writer, friend, and one of the night's performers, Amy Klein, made me think about why there are so few Hispanics at the shows I attend, including this one. I wonder if it's a problem. While I know fellow Puerto Ricans from my hometown of Newark, NJ who are into punk they don't often have a chance to go to shows. I'd think that the ideals of Hanna, particularly heard in the Riot Grrrl Manifesto, which was brought back to life with a reading from Kim Gordon of Sonic Youth, speaks to many voices. While not particularly moving in the way it was recited, the words Gordon spoke were moving and surprisingly this was the first time I heard the manifesto. I want to print it up in tiny zines and leave it in public spaces. I think it's that powerful.
From Kaia Wilson's acoustic rendition of the obscure Suture song "Pretty Is," straight to Bridget Everett's energetic and sexy performance of Le Tigre's "After Dark," the sets were awesome. Toshi Reagon got the crowd singing with "Keep on Livin," and She Murders (featuring Coco, Kim Gordon's daughter) made fists raise with "Rebel Girl." Overall, it was a fun night and got me more interested in Hanns's music. I told JD Samson how great This Island sounds on vinyl, which was pretty cool!! On another note, Hanna still make catchy as hell music! The night made me think about my place within this feminist punk rock world and made me realize how much I like dancing to Le Tigre. If there's something I can say about her music is that it allows me to feel comfortable, free, unafraid, and that ,my friends is a beautiful thing. So there's my take.
Murray Hill introduced The Julie Ruin saying:
....The best part I loved about the Le Tigre shows is the energy of all the young kids. (cheers) That's right. And all the different kind of people that the band and Kathleen brings together. This music and Kathleen actually means something, ladies and gentlemen. When entertainment has a message and a fun fucking message, you know what I say to that ladies, and gentlemen: showbiz. Alright kids, are you ready? The world debut. Ladies and gentlemen, and gay people and queer people: The Julie Ruin!
See below for photos, the Riot Grrrl Manifesto, and complete setlist from the evening.